Jeff with the scoop!
I'd say Charlotte is the winner here. Maggette will be 33 this year, while Gordon is/will be turning 29. So they get younger, which is key for a rebuilding team such as the Cats. Both guys are fairly close stats wise.
The key is the 1st rounder. Does "protected" mean that if it's a top 3 they don't get it? If it's next year, I can't see Pistons being that low. Still, top 15 pick for Charlotte along with what they have.