Originally Posted by LX
Iggy is the only player of interest for me. I don't think Josh would be good chemistry-wise, and JJ might be more effective overall, or not a huge drop off anyways. Smith has too much of JJ's bad tendencies, while not being as good a defender, and Iggy has JJ's better tendencies while upping every aspect.
I agree with a lot of your sentiment, but JSmith would still be a big upgrade. Smith's shooting numbers were his worst in 4 seasons but still better than JJ (and that's including his infuriating love of long 2's). He rebounds much better (15.9 to 11 RB% this year) and is a much better passer (20.6 to 13.9 AST%). His PER and WinShares are both much higher than JJ's. Defensive numbers are always tricky but they tend to favour Smith here as well.
All that said, I would take Iggy over Smith or JJ in a second. Iggy>Gay>JSmith>JJ >Tayshaun