Raptors Forum | Toronto Raptors Forums & Message Boards - View Single Post - harper and godwin's law - reductio ad hitlerum
View Single Post
Old 04-27-2012, 08:40 PM   #1 (permalink)

giant steps
'trane's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 15,190
Default harper and godwin's law - reductio ad hitlerum

ok, i've tried not to get into politics as much here recently, but this should be deeply insulting to everyone who cares about honesty and integrity in parliament:

The governing Conservatives are digging back into Canadian history to find a line of attack against the opposition New Democrats, who are surging in recent public-opinion polls.

For two days running, the NDP has been accused of being soft on Hitler – even though the party did not exist until 16 years after the Second World War ended.

When Christine Moore, a Quebec New Democrat, asked during Friday’s Question Period in the Commons if the Conservatives are preparing to keep troops in Afghanistan past 2014, Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird recalled that the leader of the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation, a forerunner of the NDP, was reluctant to enter the war against Germany.

“The NDP do not support sending troops abroad for anything,” Mr. Baird replied. “Let us look at what the former leader of the NDP-CCF said. ‘I would ask whether we are to risk the lives of our Canadian sons to prevent the actions of Hitler.’ It was the former leader of the NDP-CCF, J.S. Woodsworth, who said that.”

That came on the heels of Thursday’s Question Period when Prime Minister Stephen Harper said much the same thing.

“Unlike the NDP, we are not going to ideologically have a position regardless of circumstances. The leader of the NDP, in 1939, did not even want to support war against Hitler,”
he told the Commons.

Of course, the NDP did not even exist until 1961 – as opposition MPs loudly reminded the Prime Minister across the floor of the Commons. “Okay, it was the CCF, same difference,” he replied. “Parties do change their names from time to time.”

Like the Reform Party, which changed its name to the Conservatives, NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair responded. Mr. Mulcair suggested that Mr. Harper’s accusations mean it is now open season to go after the government for the policies of its own predecessors.
Why is Harper’s team invoking Hitler to debate New Democrats? - The Globe and Mail

fuck i hate this kind of politics. there is no won here, just dirty, dirty pool.
'trane is offline   Boss Key Wife Key