Raptors Forum | Toronto Raptors Forums & Message Boards - View Single Post - Vince Carter....HOFer!
View Single Post
Old 02-22-2012, 12:33 PM   #42 (permalink)
is pounding the rock!

Senior Member
Superjudge's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 17,371

Originally Posted by Shadowfax View Post
does anyone here seriously think Carter's name belongs on this sacred list ?...in the grand scheme of things, Carter had a couple of shining moments (and 1 of those is a dunk contest...hell, i've seen better dunks on youtube from a bunch of nobodys)...in the really big picture he was (and is) a good player with very mediocre results
nothing personal against the man, but i feel it would be a slap in the face to the other HOFers if he was ever inducted
imo there is a certain level of excellence that must be achieved before consideration...and he has come nowhere near that level over his career

do yourselves a favour and take another visit to the NBA History thread...read what the "greats" achieved...then come back here and tell me you still think he deserves to be included with those names...bet you can't

look at these names...imho Carter doesn't measure up to any of them

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
Nathaniel "Nate"Archibald
Paul J .Arizin
Charles Barkley
Thomas B. "Tom" Barlow
Richard F. "Rick" Barry
Elgin Baylor
John Beckman
Walter "Walt" Bellamy
Sergei A. Belov
David "Dave" Bing
Larry J. Bird
Carol A. Blazejowski
Bernhard "Bennie" Borgmann
William W. "Bill" Bradley
Joseph R. "Joe" Brennann
Alfred N. "Al" Cervi
Wilton N. "Wilt" Chamberlain
Cynthia Cooper-Dyke
Kresimir Cosic
Robert J. "Bob" Cousy
David W. "Dave" Cowens
Joan Crawford
William J. "Billy" Cunningham
Denise M. Curry
Drazen Dalipagic
Adrian Dantley
Robert E. Davies
Forrest S. DeBernardi
David A. "Dave" DeBusschere
Henry G. Dehnert
Anne T. Donovan
Clyde Drexler
Joe Dumars
Teresa Edwards
Paul Endacott
Alexander "Alex" English
Julius W. Erving
Patrick Ewing
Harold E. "Bud" Foster
Walter "Walt" Frazier
Max "Marty" Friedman
Joseph F. "Joe" Fulks
Lauren "Laddie" Gale
Harry J. Gallatin
William P. Gates
George Gervin
Artis Gilmore
Thomas J. "Tom" Gola
Gail C. Goodrich
Harold E. "Hal" Greer
Robert F. Gruenig
Clifford O. "Cliff" Hagan
Victor Hanson
Lusia Harris-Stewart
John J. Havlicek
Cornelius L. "Connie" Hawkins
Elvin E. Hayes
Marques O. Haynes
Thomas W. "Tommy" Heinsohn
Nat Holman
Robert J. "Bob" Houbregs
Bailey E. Howell
Charles D. "Chuck" Hyatt
Daniel P. "Dan" Issel
Harry E. "Buddy" Jeannette
Dennis Johnson
Earvin "Magic" Johnson
Gus Johnson
William C. Johnson
Neil Johnston
K.C. Jones
Samuel "Sam" Jones
Michael Jordan
Edward W. "Ed" Krause
Robert A. "Bob" Kurland
Robert J. "Bob" Lanier
Joseph B. "Joe" Lapchick
Nancy I. Lieberman
Clyde E. Lovellette
Jerry R. Lucas
Angelo "Hank" Luisetti
Karl Malone
Hortenciade Fatima Marcari
Peter P. "Pete" Maravich
Robert A. McAdoo
Emmett B. "Branch" McCracken
Jack D. McCracken
Robert "Bobby" McDermott
Kevin E. McHale
Edward C. "Ed" Macauley
Moses E. Malone
Slater N. Martin
Richard J. "Dick" McGuire
Dino Meneghin
Ann E. Meyers
George Mikan
Arild Verner Agerskov (Vern) Mikkelsen
Cheryl Miller
Vernon "Earl" Monroe
Chris Mullin
Calvin J. Murphy
Charles C. Murphy
Hakeem Olajuwon
Harlan O. "Pat" Page
Robert L. Parish
Maciel "Ubiratan" Pereira
Drazen Petrovic
Robert L. "Bob" Pettit
Andy Phillip
Scottie Pippen
James C. "Jim" Pollard
Frank V. Ramsey
Willis Reed
Arnold D. "Arnie" Risen
Oscar P. Robertson
David Robinson
Dennis Rodman
John S. Roosma
John D. Russell
William F. "Bill" Russell
Arvydas Sabonis
Adolph "Dolph" Schayes
Ernest J. Schmidt
John J. Schomer
Barney Sedran
Uljana Semjonova
Bill Sharman (player)
Christian "Chris" Steinmetz
John Stockton
Maurice Stokes
Reece "Goose" Tatum
Isiah L. Thomas
David O. Thompson
John Thompson
Nate Thurmond
John K. "Jack" Twyman
Westley S. "Wes" Unseld
Robert P. Vandivier
Edward A. "Ed" Wachter
William T. "Bill" Walton
Robert F. "Bobby" Wanzer
Jerry A. West
Nera D. White
Leonard R. "Lenny" Wilkens (player)
Jacques Dominique Wilkins
Lynette Woodard
John R. Wooden (player)
James A. Worthy
George H. Yardley
Superjudge is offline   Boss Key Wife Key