12/8 and holding teams to low percentages so that you only have to play 28 minutes per game is pretty AS worthy in my books.
In any case, the only thing that matters is the playoffs. Bosh
has been to a good number of meaningless AS games. He hasn't played a whole of meaningful big games. If he shows up when it counts, then he's a shoe in as an AS for many years to come. If he doesn't show up like a true star, then it's all going to be about stuff that doesn't mean shit such as likability.